Piano di Sorrento
Piano (and Sorrento) were absolutely beautiful. So nice in fact, that I never even ventured anywhere else on the Amalfi Coast or Capri. This area is wonderful if you want a vacation without feeling like you're in the middle of a tourist zone. The coastline is brilliant, with nice public beaches.
Insider Tip:Go to lunch or dinner at Le Tre Arcate in Piano di Sorrento. The food is so delicious, and the people are so kind. I was in the area for three days, and I ate there three times! Toni, the head waiter, was one of the nicest and most genuine Italian men I've ever met.