HOSTEL SEARCH



Edinburgh Hostel Reviews

Hostelworld has more reviews than anyone else! Here are some of our top rated hostels in Edinburgh...



   Print

Brodies 2 in Edinburgh, Scotland

93 High St, The Royal Mile, EH1 1SG, Edinburgh

Reviews & Ratings

The following reviews were submitted by customers who booked on Hostelworld.com in the last 6 months.

They are the opinions of the customers who submitted them and do not express the opinions of Hostelworld.com. This way, you get an up to the minute opinion of just how good a hostel really is.

Read our review guidelines »

Our Trust Rating explained

We now classify our reviewers based on how well travelled they are.

  1. 1. Novice Nomad

    1-10 Reviews Added

  2. 2. Avid Traveller

    10-20 Reviews Added

  3. 3. Globetrotter

    20+ Reviews Added

Overall Rating: 76%From a total of 56 Reviews

69% 
69% 
96% 
81% 
70% 
69% 



Sort by:     Top Rated Lowest Rated Newest Oldest Age Group Nationality Gender
  1 | 2 | 3 |    Forward One Page Go to Last Page

86% Customer Rating

Novice Nomad (5)

The staff is very polite, is very cheap and the location is great.

Alberto, Spain | Couple 25-30 | 29th November 2009

80% Customer Rating

Globetrotter (35)

They have two locations and one of them is shut down on weekdays. We booked Fri, Sat, Sunday and were forced to check out at 10am on Sunday then didnt get to go in our new dorm room until almost 5pm. One of the staff was a bit rude to us during this situation. They had advertised free Wi-Fi, but in reality the Wi-Fi was really expensive. This was a bit upsetting for us. They have a really good system in the communal kitchens and offered good storage space for guests. Location was Amazing.

AdamandKatie, USA | Couple 25-30 | 06th November 2009

80% Customer Rating

Novice Nomad (1)

really suited us and very handy to everything. the only draw back was that the hostel was uncomfortably hot. it was the general consensus from most people on our floor.

jemmima819228, Northern Ireland | Female 25-30 | 26th October 2009

53% Customer Rating

Globetrotter (25)

Excelent situation but very poor character, insufficient bathrooms, very small showers and cramped rooms. It\'s a flat converted in a hostel. Poor cleanliness in general. Anyway an adequate place to stay if you look for something simple.

kinkyjuan, Spain | Male 18-24 | 15th October 2009

50% Customer Rating

Novice Nomad (5)

Other than good location, the hostel failed in quite a few areas. There were insufficient utensils in the kitchen and those available looked dirty. Cups were chipped. The room had bad ventilation (having a very sick person who shared the room coughing throughout the night made the problem worst), the sheets had someone else's hair on it, there were no clean linens. The a few of the shower cubicles could not be locked. The hooks at the back of the door couldn't be used.

fox_fire887197, Singapore | Female 18-24 | 12th October 2009

53% Customer Rating

Novice Nomad (1)

Location is awesome but the hostel is really dirty and smelly, the sheets didnt look or feel clean yuck.

Lillian, Australia | Female 18-24 | 08th October 2009

70% Customer Rating

Novice Nomad (1)

Staff were friendly, kitchens and rooms really clean and large enough for all. Not many toilets/showers at all but only had to wait once so wasn't really a problem. Would recommend the 6bed dorms over the 16bed ones. Would definately stay again.

fi_da7829, England | Female 18-24 | 06th October 2009

50% Customer Rating

Novice Nomad (2)

The toliet and the shower are in very worse conditions, also the opening time of the kitchen causes many inconvience to the residenr, also the security is not so good

Tin Yan Jonathan, Hong Kong | Male 18-24 | 02nd October 2009

53% Customer Rating

Novice Nomad (1)

Bedlinen are not clean because they are used

Elmar, Austria | Male 31-40 | 30th September 2009

80% Customer Rating

Avid Traveller (19)

I found this to be a good hostel with all the failities. Also good location and friendly staff

christierimes4418, Australia |   | 26th September 2009


  1 | 2 | 3 |    Forward One Page Go to Last Page