HOSTEL SEARCH



New York Hostel Reviews

Hostelworld has more reviews than anyone else! Here are some of our top rated hostels in New York...



   Print

Columbus Circle Hostel in New York, USA

120 West 60th Street, New York, 10023, New York

Reviews & Ratings

The following reviews were submitted by customers who booked on Hostelworld.com in the last 6 months.

They are the opinions of the customers who submitted them and do not express the opinions of Hostelworld.com. This way, you get an up to the minute opinion of just how good a hostel really is.

Read our review guidelines »

Our Trust Rating explained

We now classify our reviewers based on how well travelled they are.

  1. 1. Novice Nomad

    1-10 Reviews Added

  2. 2. Avid Traveller

    10-20 Reviews Added

  3. 3. Globetrotter

    20+ Reviews Added

Overall Rating: 78%From a total of 482 Reviews

73% 
79% 
95% 
78% 
66% 
80% 



Sort by:     Top Rated Lowest Rated Newest Oldest Age Group Nationality Gender
  1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 |    Forward One Page Go to Last Page

26% Customer Rating

Novice Nomad (1)

NOT WORTH THE MONEY.

Patrick, Northern Ireland |   | 16th December 2009

50% Customer Rating

Novice Nomad (1)

I have stayed in hostels worldwide and this had the be the worst. No lounge area so nowhere to relax or chill and the kitchen area was closed between 11am and 5pm.Our room for 4 was only 8x10(minus a 2x2'jut-out' wall with must have housed the boiler because it was unbearably hot. Staff were indifferent to anything other than their computer screen. Will definitely NOT be staying here again and would NOT recommend it. IGNORE THE WEBSITE PICTURES,THIS WAS NOT A FUN PLACE.

secondhandrose13195392, England | Female  | 15th December 2009

80% Customer Rating

Novice Nomad (1)

When we arrived and put our luggage in the room there were some guys lying in the beds (we booked a female-room). The beds were cleaned when we moved in then but the room and the bathroom was not cleaned at all (trash on the floor, baskets not cleaned, dirty floor). Second floor (common room) was closed due of construction (from 7am to 5 pm) and so there was only the possibility to sit in the room during this time. And it was a still a construction area at night.

Veronika, Austria | Female 18-24 | 15th December 2009

73% Customer Rating

Novice Nomad (1)

Its a nice hostel, bathroom is small but in room and clean and its two blocks from the columbus circle, so where good locoation. they also have an elevator which is nice especially with luggage. I would stay there again. Thank you!!!!

Manuela, Germany | Female 25-30 | 13th December 2009

76% Customer Rating

Novice Nomad (4)

I had to cut my new york stay shortdue to an emergency, and the hostel kept almost all of my money for the entire original booking. So only book a few days at a time if you are not sure how long you are in town. Hostel clean comfortable, not warm though, had to get 4 extra blankets to keep warm at night. but excellent hostel I think.

Rachel, England | Female 18-24 | 11th December 2009

43% Customer Rating

Novice Nomad (1)

there was no possibility to use thekitchen because thez were building there. room was very small and dirty. better go to l-shostel in harlem (same owner).

Caroline, Germany |   | 10th December 2009

56% Customer Rating

Novice Nomad (2)

very Noise at night. unhappy the fact they are no longger large Lounge, wide space for dinning.. things is getting too comercial.. I am not happy the fact they take for granted previous experience was nice. I am Not Comming back!!! Bloody expensive and too crowded !!!

rudani761375, Indonesia | Male 25-30 | 09th December 2009

86% Customer Rating

Novice Nomad (1)

Very small room, but quiet and comfortable. Superb location - just two blocks from Columbus Circle! Overall a great place to stay!

kaczmarczik7280, USA | Female 18-24 | 07th December 2009

70% Customer Rating

Novice Nomad (6)

Works in the hostel. Impossible to use the kitchen for lunch. Works even during the week end, noise starting at 8AM ! will be surely pleasant after the works

Sylvie, France | Female 41+ | 06th December 2009

66% Customer Rating

Novice Nomad (1)

The floor outside the bathroom leaked with water and when we told the staff they didn't do anything about it... they did however clean the rooms really well when asked.

sofie19886214, Australia | Group 18-24 | 06th December 2009


  1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 |    Forward One Page Go to Last Page