HOSTEL SEARCH



New York Hostel Reviews

Hostelworld has more reviews than anyone else! Here are some of our top rated hostels in New York...



   Print

Harlem YMCA in New York, USA

180 West 135th Street, NY 10030, New York

Reviews & Ratings

The following reviews were submitted by customers who booked on Hostelworld.com in the last 6 months.

They are the opinions of the customers who submitted them and do not express the opinions of Hostelworld.com. This way, you get an up to the minute opinion of just how good a hostel really is.

Read our review guidelines »

Our Trust Rating explained

We now classify our reviewers based on how well travelled they are.

  1. 1. Novice Nomad

    1-10 Reviews Added

  2. 2. Avid Traveller

    10-20 Reviews Added

  3. 3. Globetrotter

    20+ Reviews Added

Overall Rating: 67%From a total of 45 Reviews

65% 
74% 
72% 
71% 
57% 
62% 



Sort by:     Top Rated Lowest Rated Newest Oldest Age Group Nationality Gender
  1 | 2 | 3 |    Forward One Page Go to Last Page

76% Customer Rating

Avid Traveller (11)

Bed bugs and roaches in the room. The first night the room was so hot I couldn\'t sleep, the last night so cold I couldn\'t sleep either. Very poor internet facilities. I have to say though, that the staff is really nice and the area is safe and ideal for a cheap stay in NYC

Irene, Italy | Female 25-30 | 12th November 2009

53% Customer Rating

Novice Nomad (1)

Good for the price. No wifi connection

Edgar, France | Male 41+ | 06th November 2009

86% Customer Rating

Novice Nomad (1)

I stayed there from Oct 28 thru Nov02 and was skeptical in the begining. The staff made me very welcome and the room was small but suitable. I was informed there was no television before my arrival so there was no let down. I did see a couple of roaches but no reflection on the Y.Houskeeping was there seven days a week maybe not the main people during the weekday but bathrooms were always clean and the lounge area could have used some new furniture still okay.

john, USA | Male 41+ | 03rd November 2009

80% Customer Rating

Novice Nomad (3)

The Harlem YMCA is for me a great place to stay. It is close to best subways and buses. There is ample shopping for groceries,or anything else. Only complaint would be that there are 5 permanent residents some of which smoke in rooms and it infiltrates other rooms. I had to be moved to avoid this. Staff is helpful and friendly. For ease of travel, this location is great. I have stayed here before and use it for extended stays of up to three weeks.

enchanter12823113, USA | Male 41+ | 26th October 2009

20% Customer Rating

Novice Nomad (1)

We stayed in this hostel for 10 days,it turned out to be a nightmare! Water pipes broke on a Friday & the whole building was flooded! Stopping the lifts for a day or two.The whole building was flooded thus stopping us to use the gym for the entire duration of the stay! Staff are so unhelpful & if not that I insisted to use the West Side YMCA gym (where I stayed in Oct 08), they wont even bother to give me a guest pass. You cant adjust the heating in the rooms & it was on all night & hot!POOREST

acolongon1107, England | Male 25-30 | 17th October 2009

86% Customer Rating

Novice Nomad (1)

The location was excellent for me because I enjoy the many services with Gospel music. It\\\'s easy to get to downtown by the subway. But I spent a great deal of time in Harlem and got to like the neighbourhood very much. The staff was very helpful. I had a small room first with a single bed and a dresser crammed into a tiny space. But when I asked for a room with a desk I got a lovely room with space and the desk and chair I required. I could stay here again if on a thight budget.

majitas5202, Denmark | Female 31-40 | 15th October 2009

73% Customer Rating

Novice Nomad (2)

I got room which had no heat, although the staff were very attentive to slid towel between the window to block the air but still no heat and it was 40 degrees out there

ah_huka1022, Indonesia | Female 31-40 | 14th October 2009

66% Customer Rating

Novice Nomad (2)

Unfortunately, the day of my arrival the heath was on and in the little room there were like 40° and there was no way to turn the heath off. The room and the bathroom were clean. The staff nice.

Chiara, Italy | Female 31-40 | 08th October 2009

83% Customer Rating

Novice Nomad (1)

It was just great staying at the YMCA Harlem. Maybe it isnīt the most beautiful part of NY, but it is friendly, real and not as expensive as other areas. The Metrostation is very close, so you can easily reach everything. The staff was helpful and friendly. The aircon was fooling around a bit, but that wasnīt so bad. I would recommend staying there!

hannavedder837, Germany | Female 18-24 | 07th October 2009

56% Customer Rating

Novice Nomad (1)

The only inquiry I have is that there is no security locks in the 11th floor of the men\'s bathroom. There is a door to the shower but it is missing its knob and the other door to the entrance as well as its door frame are badly damaged. Also the windows to the halls did not have window guards and someone can easily fell as many of these windows were left open wide enough for a child to fit. Many vagrants outside the YMCA, security needed. 4 stars!

Michael, USA | Male 31-40 | 05th October 2009


  1 | 2 | 3 |    Forward One Page Go to Last Page