HOSTEL SEARCH



New York Hostel Reviews

Hostelworld has more reviews than anyone else! Here are some of our top rated hostels in New York...



   Print

Hostelling International New York in New York, USA

891 Amsterdam Avenue, NY 10025-4403, 10025, New York

Reviews & Ratings

The following reviews were submitted by customers who booked on Hostelworld.com in the last 6 months.

They are the opinions of the customers who submitted them and do not express the opinions of Hostelworld.com. This way, you get an up to the minute opinion of just how good a hostel really is.

Read our review guidelines »

Our Trust Rating explained

We now classify our reviewers based on how well travelled they are.

  1. 1. Novice Nomad

    1-10 Reviews Added

  2. 2. Avid Traveller

    10-20 Reviews Added

  3. 3. Globetrotter

    20+ Reviews Added

Overall Rating: 75%From a total of 190 Reviews

75% 
81% 
77% 
75% 
74% 
69% 



Sort by:     Top Rated Lowest Rated Newest Oldest Age Group Nationality Gender
  1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 |    Forward One Page Go to Last Page

70% Customer Rating

Novice Nomad (1)

The free wifi is unreliable and prone to cutting out frequently. It also doesnt work with iPhones. Compared to the free wifi in other HI spots i've stayed in it's pretty poor. Everything else was ok though

laurent9381, Italy |   | 20th November 2009

73% Customer Rating

Novice Nomad (2)

currently undergoing some renovation work with excellent new bathrooms. Was such a huge hostel, the onsite cafe was a welcome touch. Location was awful though and is nowhere near the sights of New York, but around 15-20 minutes on the subway, which is a ten minute walk away. If you are short on time, stay somewhere more central.

Ryan, Ireland | Male 18-24 | 19th November 2009

96% Customer Rating

Novice Nomad (1)

everything was great except y'all should know about that shuttle from ny (pick it up at bryant part, 41st between 7th and 8th, Grand Central stn) to the Newark airport...i got these super confusing instructions from the reception, but it all worked out. but yeah...that would have been a plus.

mirrakardonne7297, Canada | Female 18-24 | 16th November 2009

80% Customer Rating

Novice Nomad (2)

was a bit surprised that someone was allowed to check in at 8:15 in the morning and was not aware that anyone else was in the room. turned on the lights and was very loud with 3 other ppl who were not staying in the room! maybe if they could be informed next time so they are not so noisy!

jung_869471, Australia | Female 18-24 | 14th November 2009

80% Customer Rating

Novice Nomad (2)

The overall experience was grand, tho i must say the luggage lockers downstairs were hard to operate and i was taken aback when the guy at the cafe said he wouldnt give me change for them even if i bought something, i was like "so you have a no change policy with all your customers then? they give you a $20 for a $2 drink and you give then $0 in return as a rule?"

indorilcaska2858, Australia | Female 25-30 | 05th November 2009

63% Customer Rating

Novice Nomad (1)

the sanitary facilities are in pretty poor condition; booking the hostel via Internet is connected with danger; defraud was commited with my creditcard;

apkallenberg4062, Germany | Male 41+ | 31st October 2009

96% Customer Rating

Novice Nomad (1)

I was in this Hostel and spend a great time there. thanks for everythings

Arturo, Mexico | Male 41+ | 27th October 2009

73% Customer Rating

Novice Nomad (1)

I reserved a four bed room and when I got there it was not available. This was not very fun to find out. I also did not like at all the painting and workers on the floors as I was going back and forth to the bathroom. There should be a discount for a hostel that is undergoing work. I will not be back.

jadeph5063, USA | Female  | 22nd October 2009

76% Customer Rating

Novice Nomad (1)

Clean place to stay with nice staff! Located in Upper West Side it's pretty far away from a lot of tourist stuff, but just one block away is the sub so you"re good =) They could need an additional bathroom on the 3rd floor though ;-)

alenareeb8600, Germany | Female 18-24 | 11th October 2009

80% Customer Rating

Avid Traveller (11)

This is a pretty good hostel, I would stay here again. The stay are helpful, pretty good, safe area, close to train station. There is a kitchen so you can cook. The bathrooms could have been nicer, but they were in the middle of rennovations, so hopefully these will improve. All up pretty good.

Simone, Australia | Female 18-24 | 30th September 2009


  1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 |    Forward One Page Go to Last Page