NOTE: 9 or more guests qualifies as a group booking, change the number of guests to return to normal search.

York Commercial Hotel Reviews

No.7 Xi Yi Road, Xi'an, China

Reviews & Ratings Explained

The following reviews were submitted by customers who booked in the last 6 months.

The reviews and ratings in the rating box are based on all-time feedback and are the opinions of the customers who submitted them and do not express the opinions of Hostelworld.com. This way, you get an up to the minute opinion of just how good a hostel really is. Read our review guidelines »

Reviews of York Commercial Hotel

  • Show Translated Reviews In A Specific Language


  • Sort reviews by:

20%

***MUST READ*** We booked to stay at the York Commercial, but when we EVENTUALLY found the hotel, the unfriendly staff took an age to inform us that we were actually staying at the Xiangzimen Youth Hostel. HOWEVER, the manager there, Jack, was extremely helpful and friendly and the Xiangzimen Youth Hostel was very nice with a great bar and cafe, which came in handy as it was raining for most of our time in Xi'an.

  • Novice Nomad
  • 17 Sep 2011
  • Anonymous
  • England
  • Couple 25-30
  • (9 reviews)


40%

Promised pick up did not happen. Borrowed broken umbrella, wanted to charge for me breaking it.. Was not possible to find, map shows hotel 1 km to the side from real location, room was not really clean, full of hairs on the floors. I would recommend NOT to try breakfast! On positive side, you could see they try hard, just skills are not there.

  • Novice Nomad
  • 11 Sep 2011
  • Anonymous
  • Lithuania
  • Mixed Group 25-30
  • (2 reviews)

Owner Comment (Show)
Hi,my friend, I think you don"t tell really reason to the hostelworld,in our hotel our staff english is no good,but all service by our manager(Jack),you take taix to our hotel,we pay taix fee for you and for umbrella,we don't need your any money.

We now classify our reviewers based on how well travelled they are.

  • Novice Nomad: 1-10 Reviews Added
  • Avid Traveller: 10-20 Reviews Added
  • Globetrotter : 20+ Reviews Added
View all Xi'an Hotels
  • 52%

  • Overall Rating
  • From 4 ratings
  • 45%Character
  • 65%Security
  • 55%Location
  • 45%Staff
  • 50%Fun
  • 50%Cleanliness

Latest Review

  • 17 Sep 2011 (20%)
  • ***MUST READ*** We booked to stay at the York Commercial, but when we EVENTUALLY found the hotel, the unfriendly staff took an ...
  • Read more...
  • Anonymous

Please give us your feedback