Just worth noting - many of the "private rooms" are rented rooms in local houses. Mine was very nice, but just worth knowing in case you were expecting a hostel!
Very impressed by this place - nice location, super-clean facilities and a good quality mattress. Pretty competitive pricing by NY standards. Only complaint is that the fire alarm went off at 7am in the morning and the staff didn't really seem to know what was going on - but I assume this is a pretty rare occurrence!